Reading Logs: The good, the bad, and the ugly

I’m a big believer in taking “status of the class” during independent reading. I love being able to tell you at any moment what my students are reading. I can look back at their reading trends and habits. And I can help them work toward their independent reading goals.

What is a reading log?

A reading log is a simple record where students track their reading, usually the date, the book title, and the pages they read. Used well, it gives students real information about their own reading habits so they can notice patterns, set goals, and grow as readers.

The pros and cons of using reading logs

Why I Still Use Reading Logs

Another part of my independent reading program is student reading logs. I know some teachers frown on them, especially if you’ve read The Book Whisperer. Before you roll your eyes, hear me out.

Have you ever heard someone say, “I would NEVER use worksheets!”? Let’s be honest. There is a time and a place for MANY things in education, and not all resources are created equal. Some of the papers I give my students are pretty decent. They challenge students and push their thinking. They give concrete examples and chances to practice. Other “worksheets” do nothing to help kids learn.

My point is simple. Yes, there are bad reading logs. Yes, there are bad ways to use them. Let me tell you what I do, and see if you might see it my way.

The Goal: Getting Into the Reading Zone

First of all, my students read. A lot. Our goal isn’t a certain number of pages or minutes. Instead, we try to get into what we call THE READING ZONE.

Student lost in a book during independent reading

The reading zone is that feeling of being lost in a book. Aunt Betty calls you for dinner, and you don’t even hear her. Your eyes are drooping, but you just HAVE to find out what happens. Getting into the reading zone is what leads to deep understanding and a real love of reading.

Selecting Just Right Books for Independent Reading

To help with this, I spend a lot of time on reading behaviors. Students learn to:

  • choose “just right” books that appeal to them
  • find smart places to read where they can stay focused
  • notice when they’re losing focus and figure out why

Tracking their reading at school and at home is one way students can collect data on their own habits. Then they can use that data to make changes when they need to.

How My Reading Logs Work

My process is simple. Students write:

  • the date
  • the title (or just an arrow if they’re continuing the same book)
  • their starting page and ending page
  • “S” for school reading or “H” for home reading
Reading logs ideas for elementary school
Here’s one reading log example to get you started!

That’s it. No parent signatures. No minutes read and no rules.

Each day when I take status, students keep their logs out on their desks. If they’re busy reading, I can grab their status right off the log.

Sometimes I notice something during status, like slow progress through a book, very fast progress, or lots of abandoned books. Then I might ask a student to study their reading log before our conference. These reading log conferences can be so telling. I hear things like:

“I noticed I haven’t been reading at home very much. My mom isn’t reminding me any more and I need to do it myself.”

“I read that entire Andrew Clements book in 3 days! I was totally in the zone…maybe I should try another one of his.”

“Mrs. A, I have already abandoned 3 books this quarter. Can you do a ‘book shop’ with me?”

(A “book shop” is one-on-one time with me in our library. Together we create a personalized book list or book bin for a student who is struggling to choose books.)

Using Reading Logs Productively

At the midpoint and end of each quarter, students sort through their reading logs and study them more closely. They look for patterns. They look for problems. And they look for improvements.

They also count up their “H’s” and “S’s.” Our “homework” is reading at home at least 5 days a week (7 is even better!), so this shows whether they’re holding up their end of the deal. Then they fill out a short reflection sheet and set a goal for the next part of the quarter.

The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

I understand that reading logs can be a bad thing.

  • Parents DESPISE signing logs and nagging their kids to fill them out. I don’t do that.
  • Students don’t like writing a response every night. (“It RUINS the book, Mrs. A!”) I don’t do that either.
  • Grading pages, minutes, or titles seems unfair. How can you compare a beginning reader to a Percy Jackson fanatic?

But a simple way for students to track their reading so they become more accountable, reflective, and engaged? I don’t see the problem. My kids never complain, and they often come up to me with amazing discoveries about their own reading.

Looking for more help getting independent reading started in your class?

Maybe one of these will help you out. This reading log collection even has some fun ones to keep things interesting!

printable reading logs
A great collection of reading logs to help your students track and study their own reading.
Student reading goals and learning targets
Looking for help setting reading goals for your lessons or small groups?
Launching a year of reading, reading lessons
A complete toolkit with lessons, anchor charts, and forms to help build a community of readers!
taking status of the class
Taking status of the class is a fabulous way to monitor your students, their reading, and so much more!

 

Do you follow me on social media yet? I'd love to connect there!

Facebook
TikTok
Instagram
Youtube

Or sign up for my email list RIGHT HERE for freebies, teaching tips, and more!

Meg from The Teacher Studio

Meg